Dust to Dust: Interments of Custer and His Soldiers After the Battle of the Little Bighorn

Citation
, XML
Authors

Abstract

Although the families and loved ones of the warriors killed in the Battle of the Little Bighorn removed all their dead after the battle, the remains of the officers and soldiers of Custer’s command had a completely different outcome. Some of their remains are still found over that ground even today.

Note: During the summer of 1985 when I worked as a battle interpreter at Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument, I spent my free time in the archives researching the reinterments of the Custer dead. This Knol is based on that research and attempts to explain the complexity of taking care of the Custer dead. Learn more by visiting the Friends of the Little Bighorn Battlefield website.
 
Bob Reece’s article originally appeared on the Friends website. [1]__________________________________________________________________________________
 
It was June 28, 1876, two days after the Battle of the Little Bighorn when the surviving officers and soldiers of the 7th U.S. Cavalry began the gruesome task of burying their fallen comrades. The bodies were decomposed, many beyond recognition, bloated and black; the effects brought about by three days of exposure from the intense sun thrashed upon the Montana prairie. To make matters even more terrible, there were widespread mutilations of the dead — crushed or decapitated heads and disembowelments.
 

The first burial was incomplete, however, for there were only a handful of spades, so most of the dead were covered with only a few token shovelfuls of dirt or clumps of sage. More important were the wounded soldiers lying along the valley floor in dire need of immediate medical attention – the nearest hospital was 500 miles away over land and down rivers. This army would have to move soon and fast, so very little time could be given the dead.  

The exemplar burials were provided for Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer and his brother Tom – only 18 inches deep, but six feet compared to the other 200 plus 7th cavalrymen. Stakes driven into the ground marked recognized officer’s graves. The officer’s name was written on a piece of paper, rolled up and slipped inside a spent cartridge, then pounded into the head of the stake for later identification. Additionally, the graves were numbered on a map.

The field on June 28 was best described by Colonel John Gibbon, “…as thickly lying in all conceivable positions and dotted about on the ground in all directions are little mounds of freshly turned earth showing where each brave soldier sleeps his last sleep.” 

After the surviving soldiers left the field, predators took their place – wolves and coyotes had their fill. Human remains became strewed about the field or outright disappeared. Eventually, the battlefield gleamed with tens of thousands of shining bones from man and horse. These would have to be reckoned with resulting in many reburials over the next five years. 
 

Actions To Recover The Dead

Throughout the following year pressures from family members were placed upon Army officials to retrieve the bodies of the fallen officers. Lt. Gen Phillip H. Sheridan would attempt to persuade the military to finance such a project. He sent a heart-rendering letter to General Sherman dated April 4, 1877. 

My dear General Sherman, 

   The wife and friends of the officers who were killed with Custer…are pressing me to bring in their bodies, and I wrote to ask if the Secretary of War will authorize the necessary expense. It is possible that there may be sufficient incidental funds in the Adjutant General’s office, or other funds at the command of the Secretary, which can be used for this purpose. The sum required will be small.

   I propose, in case it meets with the approbation of the Secretary and yourself, to bury all the bodies, except Gen. Custer, at Fort Leavenworth. Mrs. Custer wants Gen. Custer buried at West Point, and I recommend that she be gratified in this desire.

   I can detail an officer to bring the bodies down in suitable boxes to Fort Lincoln and there transfer them to the proper coffins. The satis­faction it will give to the wives, families, and friends of the officers will be very great. 

I am, General,

Yours truly

P.H. Sheridan

Lieut. General

It should be of interest to note Sheridan’s concern over receiving approval from the government for the necessary funds to complete this endeavor. Apparently Sheridan envisioned this issue to become a problem. The reality of the situation was brought to Sheridan’s attention with correspondence from the Adjutant General Office dated April 18, 1877. 

Lieut General P.H. Sheridan

Commanding Mil Div of the Mo

Chicago Ill

Sir:

   I have the honor, by direction of the General of the Army, to acknowledge receipt of your communication to him of the 4th…

   The question was submitted, by the General, to the Secretary of War who regrets that your application cannot be granted, for the reason that no appropriation is applicable to the purpose, and the accounting officers do not allow accounts for such expenses.

This news must have grieved the surviving family members. The pressure to change this decision continued with Sheridan and Sherman doing their part. These officers had always held a high regard for Custer, and in respect for his widow they most likely wanted to see her wishes fulfilled. If anyone could change the opinion of the military, these men would stand the best chance to accomplish that task. 

The next bit of news from the Adjutants Office surely brought a sigh of relieve to all involved. In a letter dated April 28, 1877, addressed to Sheridan, the military bowed to the pressure. In part it read, 

Sir: 

   Referring to letter of April 18, 1877, from this office… I have now the honor to inform you that upon a reconsideration of the subject the Secretary of War has decided to pay, from the contingent funds of the Army, for the expenses of bringing in the bodies of General Custer and the officers who fell with him — as recommended in your communication of April 4, 1877 to the General of the Army –­

   The Secretary of War requests that the expenses may be made as small as possible. 

The underline is as originally written. Not much has changed; our government was as frugal with its soldiers in 1877 as it can be today. Sheridan wrote the Secretary of War in a letter dated May 7 requesting $1,000 for the project. Being as diplomatic as possible he wrote, “An accurate account will be kept to show the use made of the money.” 
 
These official letters are revealing: Custer and his fellow officers may have been forced to lie where they fell for all eternity because the military initially refused to forfeit the funding for their disinterment. Most students of this battle have a tendency to think that no one questioned the idea of retrieving the remains of Custer and his officers; it just happened, but as it can now be understood, it took pressure from higher-ups to make this work.
 

Officers Go Home

On May 16, 1877, Lt. Gen. Sheridan directed his brother Lt. Col. Michael V. Sheridan to retrieve the bodies of Custer and his officers. Escorting him to the battlefield would be Company I, 7th Cavalry, commanded by Capt. Henry J. Nowlan who knew the graves best 
for he originally helped stake the graves and map them in 1876.
 

Arriving at the junctions of the Little Bighorn and the Big Horn rivers, on June 29, Sheridan’s party found the 11th Infantry under Lt. Col. George Buell in the midst of constructing Fort Custer. On July 1st the troops began the journey up the Little Bighorn and pitched camp near the battlefield early on the morning of July 2. The grim task would proceed on that day with men walking over the battleground placing tree stems wherever a grave was found. 

On July 3 the soldiers located, with the aid of the tree stems, exposed remains that they reinterred, and then the graves were well-packed and marked with cedar stakes. The bones of the officers, including Custer, were exhumed and placed in coffins. The officers disinterred were: Captains Tom Custer, Myles Keogh, George Yates; First Lieutenants W.W. Cooke, A.E. Smith, James Calhoun; and 2nd Lt. William Reily. Lt. Crittenden was buried where he fell as requested by his father. 

On Independence Day the soldiers continued their tasks at the Reno portion of the battlefield; bodies found in the valley and on the hilltop defense site were reburied. Officers exhumed for points back east were 1st Lt. Donald McIntosh; 2nd Lt. Benjamin Hodgson; and Acting Assistant Surgeon James DeWolf. By midday of July 4 the coffins were on their way back to Ft. Custer. Their long journey continued from there until finally reaching Ft. Lincoln by steamboat on July 11. 

Sheridan would leave the field not only confident that he had completed his mission, but that the battlefield looked better — bodies were no longer exposed. The Custer dead rested only a short time before powerful Montana rainstorms returned and washed out the fresh graves — erosion and predators continued in the scattering of human remains.

After the troops left the field, photographer John H. Fouch would take the very first photographs of the battlefield. His accomplishment would be overshadowed by Stanley Morrow’s photographs taken in 1879 and believed for decades to be the first taken of the field.

Later that summer Phil Sheridan personally visited the battlefield already finding it in a most hideous condition. It must have made him gasp but he also realized the extreme difficulty in permanently burying the dead. He ordered Lt. Col. George Forsyth to make the field presentable.  

In his official report to Sheridan dated April 8, 1878, Forsyth described the burial detail of July 21, 1877. Sixty enlisted men and three officers equipped with “spades, shovels, and picks…made a thorough and careful survey of the battlefield.” 

The report acknowledged problems with the soil being absent of clay or stones causing easy erosion, yet the graves were as good a condition as could be expected. The duration of this project took “over four hours” and a “total number of skeletons or parts of skeletons reburied was seventeen.” Forsyth described a respectable scene of the operation that resulted, in his opinion, of no human bone left unburied. However, he concluded his report with a grisly prediction. “I do not think that there will ever be a time in the spring, or after the spring rains, that portions of skeletons will not be exposed, if the remains are left there…” Forsyth left the battleground with soldiers buried, but many horse bones still littered the field exposed for all to see. No one, as of yet, had made an attempt to clear the field of this decay. 

In just over a year after the Battle of the Little Bighorn there had been a total of three burial parties. Forsyth’s concerns of exposed skeletons would become known as stories circulated back east of soldier’s bodies enveloping Custer Battlefield and dragged about by animals.  

The horror troubled General Terry to the point that he deemed it necessary that the soldier’s remains should be gathered and buried together. He ordered Lt. Col. Buell of Ft. Custer for such a mission, but the order arrived during the early winter of 1878. Because of harsh Montana winters, the expedition would not start until April of 1879. 

First Monument 1879

Capt. George Sanderson led the 11th Infantry and accompanying him was the famous photographer Stanley J. Morrow. His photographs of Last Stand Hill and the bleaching horse bones include some of the most recognized in today’s history books. 
 
 

 

Stanley Morrow’s photo of horse bones, Last Stand Hill — bottom half of a cavalryman’s boot is seen in the bottom right of photo 
 

 

The Sanderson mission gathered as many of the horse bones as possible. Even though Sanderson’s orders did not require as such, his men did their best to make the field look more presentable. And, Sanderson would build the first monument to the fallen soldiers. In his official report dated April 7, 1879, Sanderson wrote, “I accordingly built a mound out of cord wood filled in the center with all the horse bones I could find on the field. In the center of the mound I dug a grave and interred all the human bones that could be found, in all, parts of four or five different bodies. This grave was then built up with wood for four feet above ground. The mound is ten feet square and about eleven feet high; is built on the highest point immediately in rear of where Gen’l Custer’s body was found…” That was just Last Stand Hill. 
 
For the remainder of the battlefield, Sanderson’s soldiers buried the rest of Custer’s soldiers where they were found. Each grave was marked with a new stake at each head. Sanderson’s report stated that “The whole field now presents a perfectly clean appearance, each grave being remounded and all animal bones removed.” The fourth burial since the Battle of the Little Bighorn was finished, but Sanderson must have felt that it was somehow incomplete for he continued in his report, “I would respectfully suggest that…either all the remains be gathered together and placed in one grave and a stone mound be built over it, or that stone headstones be placed at each grave as they now are. Either would be an enduring monument.” 

 

 
Morrow’s 1879 photo of Capt. Keogh’s original marker 
 

Final Monument 1881

This “enduring monument” and final reburial would occur in July of 1881. The 2nd Cavalry under 1st Lt. Charles F. Roe built a foundation and placed the granite monument, as we know it today, on Last Stand Hill. Minimal grading was done to level the spot where the monument was placed — it is a myth that the elevation of Last Stand Hill was drastically lowered. Today, Last Stand Hill appears very much as it was at the time of the battle.
Roe would do his utmost to prepare a final resting place for the soldier’s remains. From Roe’s description, he made it probable that nothing except a backhoe would be able to dig out the soldier’s remains. His official report dated August 6, 1881 reads in part: 
The stones were then placed in position and a trench dug ten (10) feet from base of monument on four (4) sides, for the remains. I took great pains in gathering together all remains from the Custer Battle Field, Reno’s Hill and the valley, giving it my personal attention…so that I feel confident all the remains are gathered together and placed at base of monument, stone put immediately on top of remains, and then earth, so that now they are well buried and will never be exposed again in all human possibility.
Five years after the Battle of the Little Bighorn, the dead finally came together to lie near where their commanding officer fell. Roe was impressed enough with this place to suggest a means for future visitors to have a better understanding of the battle. His report states, “Whenever I found the remains of a man, I planted a stake well in the ground, so that future visitors can see where the men actually fell.” 

 

 
7th Cavalry Monument
© 2005 Bob Reece, All Rights Reserved

 

 

Marble Markers 1890

 
Last Stand Hill — 7th Cavalry Monument and marble markers
 
© 2005 Bob Reece All Rights Reserved 

 

Today we walk the battlefield, thanks to the vision of Roe, observing not stakes but marble markers depicting approximately where soldiers fell. Company D 25th Infantry placed 249 markers on the battlefield in May of 1890, led by Capt. Owen Jay Sweet. In his official report dated May 15, Sweet makes mention of bodies still being found exposed throughout the battlefield. “During the search for bleaching skeletons of men were found and for some reason of neglect had remained unburied and with God’s canopy alone to cover them for fourteen years.” Once again soldiers were buried and reburied. 

Many officers and soldiers did their best to respect the fallen and give them the best possible burials, but it is safe to presume that the final installment of the interments of Custer’s soldiers has not been written. Remains were discovered in the summer of 1958 at the Reno-Benteen Battlefield and most recently during the archeological digs in May 1984 and 1985 — portions of skeletons were uncovered throughout the Custer Battlefield. Their remains patiently lingered, just off the beaten path of tourists and buffs, for discovery and the contemplation of their demise.  How many more lay on the barren fields of Montana cannot be conjectured, but surely not all of Custer’s soldiers have come home.

 

____________________________________________________________________________________
 
For more information regarding the Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument, the Friends of the Little Bighorn Battlefield that help support it, and a listing of the best books to read on this subject, please visit the Friends website.

About these ads

References

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.